Join our campaign for fair tax for Scotch Whisky
In 2019, the UK government committed to "ensure our tax system is supporting Scottish whisky and gin producers." Almost two years after this promise was made, £3 in every £4 spent on Scotch Whisky in the UK is still collected in tax. Unbelievably, that could further increase in the UK Budget on 27 October.
Tax on Scotch Whisky in the UK currently stands at 70%, meaning around £3 in every £4 spent on Scotch Whisky in the UK goes to the HM Treasury in excise and VAT. In addition, Scotch Whisky is put at a competitive disadvantage compared to other alcohol categories because the tax system is "a mess", "incoherent" and "a complex – and arguably outdated – system of taxation.” These are not our words, these are the words of HM Treasury Ministers, past and present.
In the Queen's Speech in 2019, the UK government promised to "do more" to #SupportScotch and "review alcohol duty to ensure our tax system is supporting Scottish whisky and gin producers and protecting 42,000 jobs supported by Scotch across the UK." Almost two years after this promise was made, no progress has been made and the Chancellor could further increase tax on Scotch Whisky and other spirits in the UK budget, due to be held on Wednesday 27 October.
Our view is simple - with UK review of alcohol duty stalled there can be no increase to spirits duty or the competitive disadvantage faced by Scotch Whisky versus other alcohol categories.
The UK's review of Alcohol Taxation
What is the alcohol duty review?
The duty review formed part of the Conservative Party manifesto ahead of the December 2019 General Election. For many years, the SWA has argued that the current system is unfair to Scotch Whisky and that the outdated system should be reformed. In 2019, we secured commitments from the Conservatives – as well as the SNP and Liberal Democrats – that duty reform should be a priority for the next government.
The Queen’s Speech in December 2019, which sets out the government legislative plans for coming year, said that the government would “review alcohol duty to ensure our tax system is supporting Scottish whisky and gin producers and protecting 42,000 jobs supported by Scotch across the UK.”
Two years on, where are we with the duty review?
It has stalled. In October, HM Treasury launched a ‘Call for Evidence’ and the SWA has submitted a response on behalf of our members. But a year after the close of that first stage of the review, there has been no further progress - no Ministerial response and no clear timetable for reform.
Why is the tax system unfair to Scotch Whisky?
The Call for Evidence says: “when compared on per unit basis the duty system as a whole is highly inconsistent.” This is true - per unit of alcohol, Scotch Whisky - and other spirits – are taxed 16% more than wine (12% abv), 51% more than beer (5% abv) and 256% more than cider (5% abv).
You can see the unfairness to Scotch Whisky clearly in the graph below – it also shows that, under the current system, the tax on wine and cider actually decreases as the alcohol strength increases.
We think the reformed system should be clear for consumers and fair for industry. After all, the government’s own Chief Medical Officers’ guidelines on low-risk consumption say adults should drink no more than 14 units a week of alcohol. The guidelines do not discriminate between categories of alcohol, and we don’t think the tax system should either.
Will a reformed system mean less revenue for government?
No. The SWA has submitted modelling to HM Treasury which shows that a uniform duty rate of 22p per unit would be needed across all alcohol categories to keep total alcohol revenue unchanged – and that the same rate of duty for all alcohol would have wider benefits to the economy, helping to boost the UK economy by £1.15bn.
Will other alcohol categories support reform of UK alcohol taxation?
As you would expect, there are differing views across different alcohol producers. Our argument is simple – alcohol is alcohol and should be taxed according to alcohol content, not manufacturing process, place of sale or any other factor.
We have held constructive meetings with other industry bodies and will continue to do so to identify areas of mutual agreement. We recognise that the reform process does not start with a blank sheet of paper and must recognise the various starting positions of the four alcohol categories. But removing anomalies and reducing the per unit differentials between categories, as close to zero as possible, should be the ultimate goal of reform.
What are the next steps?
It doesn't have to be this way. A reformed alcohol tax system can be clearer, fairer for consumers, make UK-based businesses more competitive and continue to deliver significant revenue to HM Treasury while protecting public health. This is the goal of our campaign to reform alcohol taxation in the UK.
HM Treasury should not further increase tax on Scotch Whisky or other spirits while the review is ongoing, and the Chancellor should set out a timetable for reform in the budget on 27 October.
How can I get involved?
Help us to stop further tax increases to Scotch Whisky in the UK budget on 27 October.
Contact your MP
- Find the contact details of your MP by putting your postcode into https://www.writetothem.com/
- Your local MP is displayed, click their name
- Copy and paste the suggested letter here – please change as necessary
- Provide your full name and address – needed when contacting MPs
- Send the letter to your MP via email
Tell us you have emailed your MP by emailing firstname.lastname@example.org so we keep you in touch with our campaign to end unfair tax on Scotch Whisky.
Tweet your MP
- Find the twitter handle of your MP by putting your postcode into https://www.theyworkforyou.com/
- Tweet them to let you know you #SupportScotch – remember to tag us @ScotchWhiskySWA
Some suggested tweets below:
- The Scotch Whisky industry is the UK’s number one food and drink export and a vital part of our economy. I’ve just written to [insert MP’s Twitter handle] to help ensure @RishiSunak and @hmtreasury #SupportScotch in the budget on 27 October
- .@RishiSunak and @hmtreasury promised action to #SupportScotch – but #ScotchWhisky pays more tax per unit of alcohol than other drinks. I’ve just written to [insert MP’s Twitter handle] to ensure tax on Scotch Whisky does not increase in the UK Budget on 27 October
- £3 in every £4 spent on #ScotchWhisky in UK is collected in tax - and that could increase in the UK budget on 27 October. It's time to #SupportScotch, not further increase the tax burden - please back the campaign [insert MP's Twitter handle]